Showing posts with label surf scoter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label surf scoter. Show all posts

Friday, 17 July 2026

Crail & Musselburgh :: 08 - 09 July 2026

With birding largely reduced to short days out and the same species turning up on each visit, Kev and I have been spending more time watching butterflies and, inevitably, dragonflies and damselflies. We'd also taken in some tennis at Eastbourne for a week, travelling and spending time with friends. Everything changed on Sunday when news broke of a long-tailed shrike at Crail, Fife. Unfortunately, I was tied up on both Monday and Tuesday, leaving Wednesday as my first chance to go. Kev wasn't tempted by the prospect of the long drive, so this would be a solo trip. If time allowed on the way home, I'd also try to call in and see my mum and one of my brothers.

On Wednesday morning I was showered, packed and ready, waiting only for confirmation that the bird had remained overnight. Thankfully the early updates started appearing on the WhatsApp groups and BirdGuides, allowing for an early departure. At 5.31am the message I'd been waiting for arrived - the bird was still present. I grabbed my optics and overnight bag and headed north for Fife, stopping only once enroute for breakfast and a comfort break.

The bird had been discovered near Crail and proved remarkably faithful to the area, remaining long enough for thousands of birders to catch up with it. It was identified as a first-summer male, showing the classic combination of a black face mask and crown, grey nape, chestnut back and rump, pale underparts and a long black tail.

Its appearance was of huge significance. Before the Crail bird, Britain had recorded just one accepted long-tailed shrike, a first-winter bird on South Uist in the Outer Hebrides during November 2000. That individual became the stuff of birding folklore as severe weather made travel to the islands extremely difficult. Birders chartered boats and even aircraft in desperate attempts to reach it, but many failed before the bird disappeared, leaving relatively few fortunate enough to add it to their British lists.

The Crail bird was found by Ian Redfield, a visiting American ornithology student from Colorado who is spending the summer in Fife assisting with corn bunting surveys. While birding farmland near Thirdpart House, just outside Crail, Ian noticed a shrike that immediately struck him as unusual. Although unfamiliar with European shrikes, he recognised it wasn't quite right and sent photographs to local birders Will Creswell of Wild Crail and Chris Gomersall, who circulated the images with the cautious message: "Probably lesser grey shrike. Small chance of long-tailed shrike."

The photographs then caught the attention of experienced birder Jared Wilson, who suggested that the seemingly improbable possibility of a long-tailed shrike should be taken seriously. Once the bird was relocated and studied properly, its rich chestnut upperparts, long tail and other diagnostic features confirmed the identification, making it only the second accepted long-tailed shrike ever recorded in Britain and the first for mainland Britain.

The discovery is a reminder of just how important it is to question first impressions. The bird could easily have been written off as a more familiar shrike species, but sharp observation, combined with Jared Wilson's willingness to consider an exceptionally rare identification, resulted in one of the most memorable British birding discoveries of recent decades.

I arrived at the fruit farm shop, where a volunteer directed me to a parking space. A team of volunteers was doing an excellent job of managing the stream of visiting birders while ensuring the normal business of the farm shop could continue uninterrupted. With my optics collected, I set off along the track running parallel to the road before turning onto a tarmac path leading towards a house and outbuildings, where a gathering of birders had assembled. It was a walk of almost a mile from the car park.

As I approached, a couple walking back towards me delivered some worrying news: the bird hadn't been seen for over two and a half hours. What! After a seven-hour drive, that wasn't what I wanted to hear. Fortunately, before disappointment had time to set in, I noticed a ripple of excitement spread through the assembled birders. As I reached them, the long-tailed shrike appeared on the low branches of a distant hedgerow. I managed a quick look through a local birder's scope before setting up my own scope, then enjoyed another brief view before it dropped back into cover. A lifer ticked.

I crossed to the opposite side of the hedge, joining another 30–40 birders watching the same stretch of hedge, and settled down to wait. About 20 minutes later someone picked the bird up again, this time tucked inside the hedge rather than perched on it. Although partly obscured at times by leaves blowing in the breeze, it remained visible long enough (15-20 minutes) to enjoy some excellent scope views.

Photography, however, proved much more difficult. The combination of distance, foliage and constantly shifting branches made getting a clear shot a real challenge, although I persevered and managed a few record images.

Long-tailed shrike
Long-tailed shrike
Long-tailed shrike

Looking through social media during the afternoon, I realised just how fortunate the earliest arrivals had been. Anyone on site before 6.00am had enjoyed incredible, close and unobstructed views. A birder friend, Alan Boddington @alanbodd, had driven through the night and was among those lucky enough to witness the bird showing continuously for at least 1½ hours. He also captured some outstanding video footage of this amazing rarity.

Once the bird flew to our left it vanished and a long wait began, hoping that the bird would reappear and give some further views. Swallows and house martins swooped and cut across the crop fields between us and the polytunnels growing the fruit and in the field behind. Behind was also a clear view of the Isle of May - quite stunning scenery here. We watched the hedge where views had been obtained during the morning and the hedges beyond but for the next four hours there were "only" tree sparrows, corn buntings, yellowhammers, goldfinches, etc.

Eventually I booked some accommodation online and started to make my way back towards the car but stopped to chat with a birder and photographer who was watching the hedge from a shallower angle. I found him to be Tom Whiley from Norfolk (tomwhileybirdart.blogspot.com). Tom had been at the site for a couple of days and told me he'd taken around 2,500 photographs, having been fortunate enough to enjoy some superb views of the bird. We chatted for a while about the shrike and our respective years birding before saying our goodbyes. Unlike the prolonged performance enjoyed by the early arrivals, the bird had proved extremely elusive for most of the day following its initial morning showing.

Having seen the bird, I now had a decision to make. Should I return to the site at first light in the hope of enjoying closer views and perhaps coming away with a better photograph, or should I head round to Musselburgh and try for the surf and white-winged scoters? I'd missed both species during a family break in Fife back in April, despite spending time searching as the birds moved between Lower Largo, Leven, Methil and Wemyss, so this might be another opportunity to finally catch up with them - I decided on the latter.

After an early breakfast, and a brief stop for fuel, I arrived at the Musselburgh Lagoons car park just after 7.15am. From there I headed down to the coastal path and began scanning the sea.

There were plenty of birds on the water, but initially they all proved to be eiders. I made my way towards the area where the surf and white-winged scoters had last been reported, gradually picking up a couple of red-throated divers, a few velvet scoters and a handful of common scoters. Even so, the proportion of scoters was much lower than I'd expected, and the stretch of sea directly ahead appeared devoid of them altogether.

Realising I'd probably need to work my way back towards the mouth of the River Esk, I retraced my steps, continuing to pass raft after raft of eiders but surprisingly few scoters. After almost 15 minutes of walking, I met a young woman birder coming in the opposite direction. She had been watching the sea with another birder further along the path and pointed out a distant line of scoters offshore. She confirmed there were surf scoters among them and suggested I'd get much better views from where her boyfriend was still standing.

I continued and joined him, setting up my scope while he watched through his binoculars. A careful scan of the flock soon revealed three surf scoters, with two feeding together while a third bird kept some distance from the pair. I commented that they'd done well to pick them out at such a distance offshore. He replied that they had been watching the flock for around an hour and that the birds had been noticeably closer when they first arrived, only drifting much farther out to sea during that time. That surprised me, as high tide was still only about an hour and a half away - I'd expected the scoters to be moving closer inshore rather than heading farther out.

Surf scoter
Velvet scoter

The surf scoters first appeared during late winter/early spring 2025 and remained through the summer, autumn and winter. Their position changes constantly with feeding flocks, so one day they may be comfortably within scope range while on another they can be several kilometres offshore. They breed across northern North America and winters mainly on both the Atlantic and Pacific coasts of the continent. It is an exceptionally scarce visitor to Britain, with most records involving single birds, usually associating with flocks of other sea ducks so finding three together is highly unusual and is one reason these birds have attracted so much attention.

Chatting to the birder, I discovered that he and his girlfriend were from the Czech Republic. They had travelled to the UK for Birdfair but had arrived a week early to spend some time birding around Scotland before heading south for the weekend.

As we scanned the sea together, small flocks of around a dozen red-breasted mergansers flew past, while eight red-throated divers passed in singles and pairs. Although spread out, the divers remained loosely associated, forming a long, straggling procession as they moved steadily along the coast. A single gannet worked back and forth across the bay, plunge diving from time to time but also at distance.

Red-throated diver
Red-throated diver

At this distance it was almost impossible to determine whether any of the velvet scoters concealed the sought-after white-winged scoter, so I waited until high tide in the hope that the flock might drift closer to shore. Unfortunately, they remained frustratingly distant throughout.

Eventually I said my goodbyes to the Czech couple and began making my way back. Along the path I stopped several times to chat with birders heading in the opposite direction. None had managed to locate the white-winged scoter either, although a couple of them had enjoyed distant views of the surf scoters shortly before reaching me.

My mum called to see where I was. After briefly turning the camera on my phone around to show her the blue sea and cloudless sky, I told her I'd drive across and visit for a couple of hours before beginning the journey back to Oxfordshire.

It had been a short trip, but a rewarding one. Two year ticks had been added, one of them a lifer, while the long-tailed shrike was the sort of bird I may never have the opportunity to see in Britain again.

Year list: 268.

Monday, 31 March 2025

Broadsands, Devon :: 29 March 2025

Back in October 2022, Kev @kev07713 and I travelled to Burnham-on-Sea in search of the Kentish plover. After an incredible morning, we decided to continue on to Broadsands, Devon, where I was hoping to add cirl bunting to my life list. You can read about that day's adventures here.

Although I managed distant views of the bunting, I've since been eager to return for better views and a photo. So, when the chance arose to meet Kev's sister, Karen @hobbylovinglife, and her partner, Dean @worlebirder, for another visit to Broadsands, I jumped at the opportunity!

The cirl bunting is a relatively rare and localised bird species in the UK, primarily found in South Devon - once widespread across southern England, its population has dramatically declined. A successful RSPB reintroduction project has also established a small population in Cornwall. The shift from small, mixed farms to intensive monoculture farming has reduced food availability and rely on hedgerows and scrubby field margins for nesting and foraging. There are also now winter food shortages as they depend on weed seeds and stubble fields in winter, which have become scarce.

The males sport bright yellow underparts, black eyestripes, and a greenish-brown back whereas the females are more subdued with streaky brown plumage, resembling a yellowhammer, but with finer markings. There are thought to be around 1,000 pairs of cirl buntings in the UK which is a huge improvement from the 1980s, when numbers dropped to just 118 pairs.

The cirl bunting also has a shorter lifespan (6.1 years) than many similar-sized passerines. Species like the yellowhammer (13.2 years), chaffinch (14.9 years), and great tit (15 years) can live more than twice as long; species like house sparrows (23 years) and great tits (15.0 years) living longer, while linnets (8.3 years) and wrens (7.2 years) are closer to our buntings. Small birds generally face high predation and environmental risks, but some species with better adaptability, different feeding strategies, or migration patterns, tend to live longer.

We met for breakfast and aimed to arrive just after 8.00am, hoping to get there before the public / dog walkers became too active; an early start, especially when travelling from Banbury. Fortunately, the journey felt shorter than expected, and the break made it a comfortable and manageable hop after breakfast.

As we got ready at the cars, we immediately spotted a couple of cirl buntings among some house sparrows, chaffinches, and a dunnock - a promising start! We set up at a respectful distance, allowing the birds space to perch in the hedge and drop down to feed. I took some photos and later returned to the car for my scope, which gave me closer views and the chance to record a short video. We watched as three males and three females alternated between the hedge and the ground, until eventually a pair took flight and disappeared passed and behind us.

What a treat to have the buntings show so well and let me get that photo I'd been waiting for.

Cirl bunting
Cirl bunting
Cirl bunting
Cirl bunting
Cirl bunting
Cirl bunting
Cirl bunting

Kev wandered off and returned saying that he'd spotted a bird that he was sure was a willow warbler - we haven't heard or seen one so for this year. Kev, Karen and I walked back to see if we could confirm the ID - it was tricky as the bird was mostly flitting around the back of a dense bush and making it difficult to pick out any of the tell-tale features - a song would have helped.

Willow warblers are one of the UK’s most common summer migrants, arriving from sub-Saharan Africa each spring to breed, with early arrivals start appearing in southern England in late March and early April. They are particularly common in Scotland, Wales, and northern England, though appear to be declining in the south. They are similar to the chiffchaff but with paler legs, longer wings, and a more yellowish underside - the best way to separate the two species is by length of the primaries and by the willow's beautiful, descending, melodic warble, quite different to the repetitive "chiff-chaff" song of its close relative.

Seeing a willow warbler in March makes me feel that the spring migration is well underway. The darting behaviour we watched is classic willow warbler - they'd all be fuelling up after their long journey and although this individual was silent in a week or two we'll likely hear their beautiful, descending song as they settle into their breeding territories.

Willow warbler
Willow warbler

We had spent quite enough time with our buntings and decided to give them space while we walked up onto the cliffs for a spot of sea watching. There had been reports of surf scoter and red-necked grebes from here and it would be good to see if we could spot them. On our way up we stopped to look out over the bay and spotted a great northern diver fishing at some distance. We set up our scopes and watched for a while, hoping that our other birds might show too - but no such luck.

Great northern divers are stunning, large water birds that are seen in the south of the UK, particularly in winter and early spring. They migrate to the UK from the Arctic to spend the winter in milder waters and in summer they head back to breeding grounds in the far north, including Scotland.

They sport a stunning black-and-white patterned body with a striking black head and white throat but unfortunately, they don’t look like this in winter – then they are more subdued in appearance, usually a grey-brown body with a pale throat and darker head. They are larger than most other divers, with a strikingly long neck, a strong beak, and a noticeable 'bump' on the forehead. They are excellent divers, capable of plunging to great depths to catch fish - they can dive up to 60 meters and remain submerged for several minutes at a time. That is something on the bucket list - see divers in their summer breeding plumage - and close enough for a photo.

Great northern diver
Great northern diver

Karen had wandered off ahead while we'd stayed to watch the diver and when we caught up with her on the clifftop vantage point, she'd already located the two red-necked grebes.

Red-necked grebes are a special sight in the UK, as they’re mostly winter visitors - seeing them in spring could mean they're on migration, possibly heading to Scandinavia or Eastern Europe to breed. They weren't quite in full breeding plumage with a deep chestnut neck and black cap but were part way there - they were good value through the scope, but distant to capture in the camera.

We picked up another great northern diver, a gannet, and Kev called a fulmar, although I didn't get on it.

We scanned for a while until eventually Dean called the surf scoter; a first-winter drake surf scoter has been reported at Broadsands since 10 December 2024 and as they often do, it was associating with a common scoter. Our bird has been difficult to see at times and I think Dean and Karen have tried unsuccessfully for it before - our luck was in today.

Surf scoters are quite rare in the UK - these sea ducks are more commonly found in North America, but they occasionally turn up along the UK's coasts during winter months, usually appearing between October and March.

The males are easily recognisable by their black plumage, bright orange bill with a distinctive yellow spot near the base, and their white wing patches. Females are more subdued with dark brownish-grey plumage but still have the characteristic bill shape. They can be harder to identify but are still distinctive once you know what to look for. Most UK records involve individuals or small groups and are often observed among other species of scoters.

It was extremely distant and required careful focus even through the scope, but its key identification features were clear, so we were satisfied. There was no chance of getting a photo, so I attempted a video, though even that proved challenging at such a distance.

After some time we decided that we would try for another bird and noticed that the hoopoe visiting at Seaton Bowls Club had been reported again and so made our way there. On arrival we got the news that it had flown a little over an hour before we got there, when the clock bell rang. It had shown well and hadn't even flushed when the groundsman cut the grass - he said it had been there for four days and fed on the green. Surely it would return ...

We waited for as long as we could before the drive home. We left Karen and Dean there - they had a shorter journey home - but the bird never returned. Shame, but it didn't spoil a cracking day out.

Year list: 151.